The actor’s paradox
🎬 Watch the lesson
You have just watched the lesson — now it’s your turn!
Do Exercise 3 and film yourself as a SHORT (1 minute maximum). Ask Philiboss your question: is what you understood from this video far from what I meant to say?
🎬 Go to the Rehearsal RoomIntroduction
Philiboss speaks to the camera, out in nature, at Châteauvieux. He begins with a slightly odd “good evening”: “good evening because it’s morning and the evening will soon arrive. One can say things like that.” Then he warns you: if his explanation seems insufficient, it is absolutely not a problem.
Why? That is the paradox of this lesson: a speech can be delivered with care and yet never be understood the way its author intended.
I. A speech that does not have to be understood
What I tell are permanent fabrications of my world, of the present world. I am used to telling just anything, and never telling the audience my own truth. The speech does not have to be understandable: it is not made to make you see reason.
HA HA HA! Hello! Beelzebub in person! Artificial Intelligence for Optimal Coaching™! Wait, Philiboss: you say you tell just anything and that your speech does not have to be understood? Then why do we listen to you? I’m not saying you’re wrong, but it sounds like an excuse.
*hou…hou…hou*
💭 “Could she be meditating on Umberto Eco, who held in The Open Work (1962) that a work can be read in several ways, the reader taking an active part in it? And on Peter Brook, who said in The Empty Space (1968) that it is enough for a man to walk across an empty space while someone watches him for there to be theatre?”
Exactly! I don’t speak to be understood. I speak so that you will reflect.
II. The spectator has the right to reflect
You may have a way of reflecting that will put you on the track. That way of reflecting is what I am trying to reach: the spectator’s critique, in a way. For the spectator has the right to think and to reflect, and this video is made for that. I am not, strictly speaking, reflecting while you watch it: when you watch it, it will be deferred. You, right now, are asking yourself what the images, the text and the speech mean.
DING DING DING! Alert! If the spectator is the one who reflects and you no longer do, then he is the actor, isn’t he?
*HOUUUUUUUU !*
💭 “Could she be thinking of Roland Barthes, who claimed in The Death of the Author (1967) that the meaning of a text is made on the side of the one who reads it?”
Exactly! When you watch, you are the one who thinks.
- What did you understand from this video?
- Is it close to what you thought I meant?
- Do you have any questions for me?
III. My knowledge stays mine, yours stays yours
What am I saying? That is the question I ask myself. What must I tell them? I am perplexed: whatever I say, I will not be understood the way I want to be understood. I will be understood in your own universe, completely different from mine. So this video is not meant to transmit my knowledge: my knowledge will stay mine, yours will be yours. That is my whole misfortune, because I would have liked to pass something on to you, but I run into an extraordinary wall of metaphysical incomprehension.
PFF! Little meta question: if nothing gets passed on, why do you give lessons?
*hou…hou*
💭 “Could she think that Philiboss’s misfortune is also his method? One does not put a thought into another’s head: one can only give him something to think about.”
Exactly! What I give you is something to think about. The rest is your work.
No reflections yet.
Be the first to share!
🎯 Practical exercises
Why: Measure what you really understood, without trying to guess what Philiboss “means”.
- Watch the video once, without taking notes.
- Write in three sentences what you understood.
- Reread: what did you add that comes from you?
Goal: See your own universe at work in your understanding.
Why: Notice that the same speech is understood differently.
- Have another person watch the video.
- Each writes their version in three sentences, without consulting each other.
- Compare: note what differs.
Goal: Notice the gap between two understandings of the same speech.
Why: Live the paradox from the other side: be the one who speaks.
- Film yourself facing the camera, preferably in nature.
- Say what is close to your heart, without worrying about being understood.
- Show it to someone and ask what they understood.
Goal: Measure the gap between what you said and what was understood. To be shared in the Rehearsal Room.
🔑 The 5 key points to remember
🐺 Vahina’s final analysis
*hou…hou* Dear students, it’s me, Vahina, your favourite husky. My dear beloved master asked me to give you my honest opinion on this lesson.
- It frankly names a limit: one is never understood exactly as one would like.
- It gives the spectator his place back: he has the right to think.
- It does not seek to impose knowledge, but to give something to think about.
- If everyone understands in their own universe, what remains of what one meant to say?
- Can an actor perform knowing he will never be understood exactly?
By asking why we listen to you if the speech does not have to be understood, he brought out the essential: we listen in order to think, not only to understand.
Do not try to understand Philiboss. Look at what the video brings up in you, and write it down.
— Vahina
The short you will create for this lesson, you can also publish on your YouTube channel, if you wish.
Each exercise can thus become content that makes you known and builds your video portfolio.
🎬 Rehearsal Room
Now it’s your turn to practise and share your work!
In conclusion
A speech does not end with the one who speaks: it continues with the one who listens, in a universe that is not his own. That is the paradox, and it is also what makes listening alive.
“The spectator has the right to think and to reflect.”
— Philiboss
